JAPANESE ANGELICA TREE ERADICATION FROM MORRIS PARK, 2013

What has become a tradition, every February, on the week of Presidents Day, The Philadelphia Parks and Rec staff and the volunteers of the Sanguine Root collaborate on a very focused task of eradicating the invasive Japanese Angelica tree from Morris Park. All year long, us volunteers pluck the tiny seedlings and saplings from the soil, numbering in the thousands. It is an ongoing effort to deplete the seedbank which has been replenished year after year by flowering and fruiting mature specimens that create complex and intensive root systems. These mature specimens require herbicide as a control, even as we remove as much as we can by hand -pulling, there is still that bigger problem.

This species is aggressively appropriating habitat all across Philadelphia at an alarming rate. If an area of forest experiences canopy failure from the results of other invasives, the Angelica tree is one of the first on the scene.  In forests where oak trees would normally drop their acorns and grow new trees, and a wide variety of shrubs would grow, now grows this monoculture of invasive trees, shading out all of the indigenous forest understory shrubs and herbaceous plants, and most disturbingly, the young trees, the saplings and seedlings are missing entirely under the darkness of this invasive Asian tree. The future of the forests of Fairmount Park are being threatened by this species.

It has become an effort to save the  urban forest, because every effort to help young trees germinate and grow is worthwhile, and this is an obvious one considering the proliferation of this noxious species throughout the Parks of Philadelphia.

sabelle removes Burning Bush with weed wrench
Isabelle removes Burning Bush with weed wrench

Several years ago, we were tasked by the City of Philadelphia Parks and Rec to map out the populations of the Japanese Angelica tree (Aralia elata) so we could then use the map to determine a course of action for their eradication.  Using the map we created, we were then able to create a strategic plan of eradication sites, which we have been doing since 2011.

We have a pretty good knowledge of all the populations in Morris Park, and we acted as guides for our staff partners at Parks and Rec, who are equipped with Garlon 4  ultra herbicide, loaded in tanks they carry on their backs.  We showed them the infestations of mature, flowering specimens and stayed out of the way , removing another invasive, the Burning bush (euonymous alatus) with a Parks and Rec supplied weed wrench as they sprayed the Japanese Angelica trees with a basal bark herbicide application.

leave the area as if there was never a problem in the first place
leave the area as if there was never a problem in the first place

Our Burning Bush removal operation proceeds as follows: we pull out the bush and leave it on site, roots out of the ground where it will die in a few weeks and decompose back into the earth within five years. The disturbance from pulling the bush out of the soil becomes the next issue of concern. We sometimes find other plants attached to the extricated shrub, such as Mayapple and on this day we found the Spring Beauty (Claytonia virginica) an ephemeral Spring flower that grows out of a corm.

Pictured above,  Sanguine Root volunteer Sean Solomon has just replanted roots of Spring Beauty and Mayapple that were uprooted along with the invasive shrub, Burning Bush. The soil is put back and the leaf cover is replaced as if there was never a problem.

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removala workday

Hopefully our efforts at removing these invasive shrubs  will result in the germination and sprouting of native canopy trees. We have had success with this phenomenon occurring in several other sites in Morris Park where we have removed invasives.

 Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

Above is an infestation of the invasive Burning Bush. Underneath the large stems were hundreds of seedlings that we pulled out by hand. The largest stem was then cut and Parks and Rec environmental technician Luke Rhodes carefully applied herbicide on the cut stump.

Euonymus alatus
Euonymus alatus

Above, the stems and corky wings of the Burning Bush.
IMG_8685
Above, these are the specimens of the native spring wildflower Claytonia virginica, the Spring Beauty, we  found in the uprooted Burning bush.

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

Luke applies a basal bark application of herbicide to the Japanese Angelica tree.

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

A Black-Haw Viburnum shrub was discovered in our work area. Finding this native shrub was an exciting moment in our day.

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

Sanguine Root Volunteer Isabelle Dijols cuts the noxious invasive Japanese Honeysuckle off of the young trees.

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

Above, the  invasive Japanese Angelica Tree, in the foreground. For a great introductory essay on this subject with references, please see our post The Japanese Angelica Tree Rapidly Invades Morris Park.  Click here For photos of  blooming flowers and a photographic guide describing the botanical differences between the North American native Devils Walking Stick (Aralia spinosa) and the Japanese Angelica tree.

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

Luke, Rhodes, Isabelle Dijols, and Tom Dougherty, and below with Sean Solomon, Isabelle and Tom.

Going out and removing invasives is a great way to get exercise and be outdoors all the while accomplishing something of great environmental value and community service!

Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday
Our annual Japanese Angelica Tree removal workday

BURNING BUSH!

THE ONGOING PROJECT OF REMOVING THE BURNING BUSH (EUONYMUS ALATUS) FROM MORRIS PARK CONTINUES. WE OFFER YOU A FEW TIPS ON ITS REMOVAL, AND A QUICK LESSON ON TELLING THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE NATIVE HEARTS-A-BUSTIN’ (EUONYMOUS AMERICANA) AND THE INVASIVE BURNING BUSH.

The invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
The invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

(Euonymus alatus)

This bush gets its common name from the bright red foliage in the fall. It was a favorite for landscapers for too long, and can be found on foundation plantings next to commercial buildings and alongside roads and parking lots. It has spread into the adjacent forests, and here it is in Morris Park.

Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

Here is a clump of this species growing in the park. It is extremely shade tolerant, and when leafed out, will shade out the herbaceous layer of the forest, leaving a barren area below it. It seeds itself prolifically, creating a problematic situation, as the forest becomes less and less of  itself and more and more about this messy alien shrub. Habitat for species -specific insects is lost, and with the diminished insects, the birds we love to have in our park are also diminished.

So now, removal is the best thing that can be done. It is a great cardiovascular exercise, and a good excuse to be outside, doing something useful for your neighboring forest.  We will help you identify them and remove them.

Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

The most tell-tale give-away is the corky winged branches of this simple-leaved shrub. The wings occur at 90 degree angles to each other and are a very prominent feature. The red fall color and the bright red berries are also distinguishing.

We mechanically remove the bush with a large steel weed wrench supplied to us by the friendly and knowledgable staff of the Philadelphia Parks and Rec department. We bought our own saws and clippers and cut out most of the bushes mass, leaving a three foot stump.  That way it is easier to pull out the roots, without brushing up against the plant and having it get in our faces as we wrestle with it, exposing us to ticks.  Wear your socks over your light colored pants and inspect yourself and wash your clothes and take a shower after this work day!  The conditions in a forest that would have a Burning bush infestation are also likely to have a deer and disease-carrying tick infestation.

Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

This great tool makes it easy to pull out the roots. This process is dirty, as the soil is spread all over as the root is unearthed. If we do not do this, and just cut the bush down, it will re-grow again, rapidly.  Removing the bush this way disturbs the soil and there may be an exposure of the roots of native herbaceous plants, insect eggs and insect habitats. This is problematic and some may prefer to just cut the bush down and return to every single bush year after year and keep cutting it down until it hopefully finally dies, with the soil left in place. This is the ideal methodology, but will require the extreme care and follow-through of the most thoughtful and attentive land steward.

Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

If you choose the pull-it-all-out method, be aware of the roots of native plants, and make an effort to put them all back with an inch or so of soil put back on top. Cover the area back up with leaves, so it looks as if there never was a bush there in the first place. The idea is to make as few changes as possible to the forest ecosystem. The best job is the one that looks as if there was no work done in the first place.

What to do with the Bush after it is removed?  We leave the bush on the site, cut up and scattered about, the roots hung up on old branches, not touching the bare soil. Very rarely will a pulled-out bush reattach itself to the soil and re-grow. It may look a bit ugly at a first glance, but within a few short years the site will look like a healthy forest again, and the Burning bush will have decomposed into the soil, providing bio-mass for the native plants that will return. Think of what the site will look like in five years!

Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

If you choose to not pull out the roots and still want to kill the bushes, consider herbicides.  In our situation as volunteers, we are not permitted to use them, so are left with the pulling and cutting options. Consider a glysophate herbicide, with a cut-and-paint approach or basal bark application, in the late winter. Be sure to know if you are allowed to use herbicides if it is on public property.

As far as the issue of soil disturbance from pulling out the roots manually goes, this may actually be beneficial in the case of severe infestations, because it has the potential to bring to the surface long dormant seeds of native plants that will have the opportunity to sprout after the bushes have been removed.

 Jason Puglionesi removing the invasive exotic Norway Maple, which we found growing amidst the Euonymus alatus, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Jason Puglionesi removing the invasive exotic Norway Maple, which we found growing amidst the Euonymus alatus, Morris Park, Philadelphia

Even if your method is in need of refinement, just by addressing the problem at all is a great start to improving the forest you are adopting. As you go, you can discuss the finer points of your environmental restoration efforts with your neighbors and all those interested and engaged with the forest.

Sean Solomon removing the invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia
Sean Solomon removing the invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

HOW TO TELL BETWEEN THE NATIVE EUONYMUS AND THE INVASIVE EUONYMUS

The invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia
The invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia

The invasive Burning Bush, (Euonymus alatus) above. Also called the Winged Euonymus. The corky, almost papery wings are very noticeable. On some specimens, the wings are not so pronounced, but they are still in evidence.

Pictured below is the native Euonymus americana, the Hearts-a-Bustin’ or Strawberry bush. While there are similarities of these two related species, the differences are distinctly noticable. The native one has  much smoother, green branches, lacking the winged habit of the invasive exotic.

The native Euonymus americana, The Hearts-Bustin' or Strawberry Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia
The native Euonymus americana, The Hearts-Bustin’ or Strawberry Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia

The seed production of the native one is unforgettable, the way the bright red fruit appears to burst out of the rough pink casing.

The native Euonymus americana, The Hearts-Bustin' or Strawberry Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia
The native Euonymus americana, The Hearts-Bustin’ or Strawberry Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia

The habit of the native bush is open and airy, whereas the invasive one is denser.

The native Euonymus americana, The Hearts-Bustin' or Strawberry Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia
The native Euonymus americana, The Hearts-Bustin’ or Strawberry Bush, Wissahickon Valley Park, Philadelphia

Above, the native, below the alien.  Note the differences (pink fruit casing on the native) in the fruit, as well as the similarities. (the red berry).

If you are unsure of the status of a specimen, do not attempt to eradicate it! Native and non-native Euonymus can grow side-by-side.

The invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush,Morris Park, Philadelphia
The invasive exotic Euonymus alatus, the Burning Bush, Morris Park, Philadelphia

When you pull out the infestations of this bush from your adopted forest, you may be surprised to see what will grow in their place in the following years. Be prepared for numerous seedlings of the invasive alatus to pop up, that you will need to weed out, but also be ready for native surprises to emerge from a soil that has not had a late spring sun grace it in many years!

If you feel you really need to plant something as a replacement, then go ahead and purchase the native Hearts-a-bustin’ at the many native plant nurseries that offer it.  Please let us know how your invasive removal project is going!  Your comments and insights are much appreciated!

 

GREAT HORNED OWL HOOTS AS THE SUN SETS

THE SUN SETS WHILE WE REMOVED VINES FROM SMALL TREES
THE SUN SETS WHILE WE REMOVE VINES FROM SMALL TREES

The hooting began around 5:30 this evening and continued at regular intervals for about 20 minutes. The weather was for the first time in recent memory, much warmer (in the 40s) and sunny. The sunset made a nice glow on the forest.

a fleeting warm glow from the setting sun
A fleeting warm glow from the setting sun

Today the volunteer staff of the Sanguine Root focused on removing vines growing on small trees in an especially hard-hit area.  We encountered a variety of situations and species.  The biggest success story is a mature Dogwood tree (Cornus Florida) that had grape vines  all over it last Spring, hanging so heavily, the tree was in danger of collapse.  In June of 2010, the vines were clipped. Today, those vines were removed from the tree, leaving it with a great form and intact integrity.  Hopefully it will flower this upcoming spring.

The Grape vines had claimed another Dogwood however. This one had all of its main branches broken.  The vines were removed and  the broken branches pruned off.  There is hope because new shoots were coming up from the stump-like top of the tree.

As much as we love the native grape vines, they are a woodland edge species, that grow in areas with a decent amount of sun, like river banks, and the edges of forests. In the blighted areas of Morris Park, the woodland edge species have an advantage when there are so many trees missing from the equation. With this advantage, they can become aggressive and destructive, perpetuating a situation of canopy holes, which benefits the vines further.

Woodland pioneer Sassafrass overtaken with Grape Vines.  Morris Park Philadelphia
Woodland Pioneer Sassafrass overtaken by grape vines. Morris Park Philadelphia

With the issue of grape vines, we must ask ourselves, what do we want?  If we want a forest, then the vines need to be controlled and monitored, so that trees can grow from saplings to maturity.

Being that our section of Morris Park is a Fairmount Park woodland area, it is our mandate to maintain this status.

Whether or not the grape vines that are growing here are even native has not been determined to our knowledge.

The Sassafrass tree to the left was in danger of having all of its main branches broken.  However, this afternoon, the vines have been removed, and the tree should be good to go. This specific specimen had a great well rounded sassafrass form, and it contributes to the health and well-being of this forest under stress.

Isabelle rescued this small tree from the invasive exotic Multiflora Rose
Isabelle rescued this small tree from the invasive exotic Multiflora Rose

This one we have not yet been able to identify.  It may be a crabapple. The Rosa multiflora and the Lonicera japonica (Japanese Honeysuckle) were having the run of the place until they met Isabelle Dijols (Homo sapiens sapiens).  After the vines have been removed, this tree now has a chance of survival.  We will revisit this specimen, identify it and rephotograph it in the spring. Look forward to updates on this specific tree. ( note the iconic pair of Tulip Poplars in the backround (Liriodendron tulipifera).

In just a few hours time, many trees and shrubs were de-vined.  A fine specimen of Black Cherry (Prunus serotina) was de-vined and there were numerous Spicebush (Lindera benzoin) that were over-run with Lonicera japonica . Also notably, was Pignut Hickory (Carya glabra).  The hickories fare the best when covered with vines, although they can still be broken and severely compromised . Even the tree that is used for hammer, axe and mattock handles can be brought down by invasive vines.

Burning bush roots(Euonymus alatus)  Morris Park Philadelphia
Burning Bush roots Morris Park Philadelphia (Euonymus alatus)

The Burning bush (Euonymus alatus) was pervasive in this area, and we pulled them up.  The shallow root system and the loose soil makes this possible. With this plant, we always make sure we get every part of it out of the soil, otherwise it will regrow. Removing it from the soil requires lots of gentle tugs and back and forth movements. Eventually we can actually pull up on the stem and get the whole plant out, leaving no roots behind. The best time to do this is when the soil is wet and loose, like it was today.

Once removed, we try to put the soil back the way it was and put the leaf layer back on top. Soil is to be disturbed as little as possible. The best work is the work unnoticed, as if there was never a problem in the first place. Disturbed soil can lead to all kinds of problems.  Invasive plants can get a better foothold in disturbed soil, from seed germination to encroachment from roots.

Last night the fog rolled in and the forest was enchanting
Last night the fog rolled in and the forest of Morris Park was enchanting

It was a quiet and peaceful day in Morris Park.  One of our pruners lost a spring and 15 minutes was spent looking for it with no success. One specimen of Japanese Barberry was found with some alarm. Many small trees and shrubs have been readied for the spring.

The last photo here was taken last night as a gentle fog rolled into the area.  Fog is a welcome sight in the beginning of February. A subtle reminder of spring that is only less than 50 days away.